Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

I’m the most dangerous person at your dinner party.

I’m the one that lingers near the Deviled Eggs at a party.  (If not Deviled Eggs, I can also be found lingering near the homemade guacamole or cheese plate.)

You’ll never ever know how many Deviled Eggs I’ve eaten because I pop the entire bite in my mouth while you’re looking down at your wine glass…. and I chew quickly.  I go back for seconds (which you think are my firsts).  I go back for thirds and fourths (which you think are my seconds).  I will clear you out of nearly every Deviled Egg on your appetizer table.

The worst part is (my breath?) that I have no remorse.  I eat all of your eggs then I casually move along (…probably to the table with wine).  I’m the worst.  I really am.  At least I won’t mess with your music selection, unless I do.  Again… I’m the worst.

Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

These eggs are extra-special because they’re dill-y and radish-y, and I was feeling extra-special when I made them.  Just let it happen.

Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

The most important part of making beautiful Deviled Eggs is first, correctly boiling the eggs and successfully peeling the eggs.  There’s nothing worst than fighting with the egg white while peeling.

I’ve had the most success with lowering cold eggs into boiling water, and boiling the eggs for 13 minutes.  I shock the eggs in cold water and huzzah!  They peel without a fuss!

This eggy article explains all.

Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

Easy peeled eggs and golden yellow yolks.  No grey, no chalky yolks.

The yolks are combined with mayonnaise, two different kinds of mustard, a dash of Worcestershire, chives, and dill!

You can use a fork to combine the ingredients for a more rustic and chunky Deviled Egg.  A food processor will create a more smooth and lovely filling.  I used a food processor.

Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

Un-yolked whites.  Imperfect is just fine.

Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

Yolks, mayonnaise, and mustard in the food processor.  Herbs and Worcestershire are stirred in.

Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

Season to taste, and then it’s hard to stop tasting.

Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

Each white is topped generously with filling and sprinkled with extra chives and dill, thinly sliced radish and yummy smokey paprika.

Then just go ahead and pull up and chair and get weird.

Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

makes 2 dozen

Print this Recipe!

1 dozen large eggs

1/2 cup mayonnaise

2 teaspoons Dijon or whole grain mustard

2 teaspoons yellow mustard

1/2 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce

3 tablespoons chopped fresh chives, plus 1 tablespoon more for garnish

2 tablespoons chopped fresh dill

salt and pepper to taste

thinly sliced radishes, for garnish

paprika for garnish

To make the eggs, fill a large pot with water about 5-inches high and bring water to a rolling boil over medium heat.  Take the eggs out of the refrigerator just as the water comes to a boil and use a large spoon to lower the eggs, one at a time, into the boiling water.  After a few eggs, the water will cool and stop boiling.  That’s ok.  Keep adding eggs.  It will start to simmer again. Once the last egg is added, set your timer for 13 minutes.  Use the large spoon to gently stir the eggs around the pot just a bit.

Prepare a large bowl with cold water and ice cubes.

After 13 minutes remove from the heat and spoon each egg out of the boiling water and into the ice bath.  Allow to fit for 5 minutes until cool to the touch.  Crack eggs and return to the water.

Peel the eggs.  Rinse them off to remove any shell bits. Pat the eggs dry.  Slice the eggs vertically and carefully spoon out the yolks into a medium bowl (if you’re mixing by hand) or the bowl of a food processor fitted with a blade attachment (if you’re mixing in a machine). Place the egg white halves of a baking sheet or serving platter.

Add mayonnaise and mustards to the egg yolk.  Mash and stir with a fork (for a more rough/rustic Deviled Egg), or blend until smooth in a food processor (for a more smooth Deviled Egg).  If using a food processor, transfer mixture to a medium bowl and stir in Worcestershire sauce, chives, and dill.  Stir.  Season to taste with salt and pepper.

Spoon about 2 heaping teaspoons into each egg white.  Top with more chives, dill, thinly sliced radish, and a sprinkling of paprika just before serving.  Eggs are best within two days of preparing.  Serve chilled.  

45 thoughts on “Extra-Special Deviled Eggs

  1. These look so good! My eggs never turn out this pretty after the peeling process – can’t wait to try putting them back into the cold water after they’ve been cracked. I think that’s the step I’ve been missing!

  2. Years ago I saw a special on TV about a company making hard boiled Easter eggs. They said their secret to getting the eggs just right was to steam them vice boiling them. I decided to give it a try. I use my electric vegetable steamer and have found that I can put the eggs in, set it for 22 minutes, and then go do whatever I need to. The eggs steam for the exact amount of time, and then are ready to go into the fridge. They always come out perfect, regardless if I am steaming 4 eggs or a dozen.

  3. I’m the same love, love, love those devilled eggs! I’m always near the savoury stuff. You can have the sweet stuff, I won’t fight you for it lol

  4. Hooray for deviled eggs! And the radish and dill combination is so perfect. I usually throw both of those into my egg salad, so the stretch to deviled eggs is not very far at all! :)

  5. Wanted to try to cooking technique to see how well it worked. Worked perfectly. Had to make egg salad. My wife is recovering from knee replacement surgery and really wanted some. So, will make the deviled eggs next time.

  6. you must try horseradish and wasabi mustard with these! also the paprika is extra awesome, maybe and olive slice on top.

  7. Joy the Baker: where amazing things become flawless things. I will be making these and then quickly eating them before anyone else has a chance to steal them from me.

  8. My mom used to top hers with perfectly pink shrimp when she hosted dinner parties, and ever since then, I’ve been a devoted fan, so much so that I’m the person right next to you at the party. Co-conspirators, as it were. I’ve been thinking of doing an all-deviled-egg cocktail party…this variation will definitely be on the menu! Thanks, Joy.

  9. When I was on Kauai we made them with lilikoi/wasabi mustard and a seaweed salad garnish. WHAT?!! They lasted less than 3 minutes. Sorry I can’t find a photo. If I do I will post it.

Leave a Reply