• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Joy the Baker
Joy the Baker
  • New Magazine!
  • Bread
  • Cookies
  • Cakes
  • Pies
  • Recipes
    • All Recipes
    • Biscuits
    • Muffins
    • Cupcakes
    • Drinks
    • Breakfast
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Fruit
    • Nuts
    • Buttermilk
    • Chocolate
    • Vanilla
    • Holiday
    • Healthy
    • Gluten-Free
    • Vegan
  • Blog
    • Baking 101
    • Tips
    • Beyond the Kitchen
    • Let It Be Sunday!
    • New Orleans

Peanut Butter Cup Christmas Cookie Recipe

December 4, 2020 by Joy the Baker 31 Comments

Jump to Recipe

What do you do when you can’t sleep? Think of peanut butter cookies then get up and start baking?

There are two schools of thought.

The first: toss and turn it out. Stay in bed, take several deep breaths, and try to take your mind from the things that make it a hamster wheel. Don’t. I repeat, do not pick up your phone to check the time or compare yourself to impossible people on Instagram. Just… you know… gently fall back into a peaceful sleep.

My brain has never let me do this, even once.

The second school of thought is one I subscribe to. Get up. Get out of bed. Walk a few blurry-eyed laps around the house while the coffee brews.  Write but schedule a few work emails as to not seem fully unhinged.  Most importantly, and after your first cup of middle-of-the-night coffee, turn on The Christmas Chronicles to watch it for the third time and make a few batches of cookie dough to freeze for future cookie tins.

Which brings us to here and now, 5am Friday December 4th in New Orleans.  I can say with confidence that I have a double batch of this peanut butter cookie dough in the freezer for cookie tin deliveries next week. It’s casual and I don’t mean to yell but THESE ARE THE BEST COOKIES OF THE SEASON. My mom makes these cookies with Hershey’s kisses every year. She calls them Love Cookies. I’ve taken liberties and added Reeses peanut butter cups, making the cookies quite amiable to cookie swap boxes and holiday care packages.

The offering today is simple peanut butter and chocolate pairing. I hope this finds you well rested.

Here’s what you need to make these Christmas Peanut Butter Cookies:

•  all-purpose flour, baking soda, baking powder, and just a bit of kosher salt.

•  softened butter and peanut butter.  For these cookies I tend to use peanut butter with additional oil like Skippy or Jiff.  It’s like adding shortening to the cookies which help create a more tender cookie.

•  two sugars, brown and white.

•  an egg.

•  chocolate candies. Peanut butter cups preferred though anything chocolate is encouraged.



 

In a medium bowl we’ll whip together softened butter with peanut butter and the two sugars.

Blend until well combined and nearly fluffy.

Beat in the egg.

Add the dry ingredients and stir together into a soft but thick dough.

I like to refrigerate the dough for 30 minutes or so while the oven preheats though this dough can go straight into the oven.



The option is to roll each dough ball in a bowl of granulated sugar before baking.

Bake the cookies until just a hint of golden brown kisses the edges. Remove from the oven and, while the cookies are still hot, press a peanut butter cup into the center of each cookie.

The chocolate candy will soften and melt within the warm cookie at which point you’ll want to shove at least three into your mouth. That’s your right as baker and I encourage it.  I recommend letting these cookies rest at room temperature until the cookies have cooled and the chocolate has set.

If you’re not going to enjoy these cookies right away, I like to wrap them individually and store them on the counter or in the freezer.

Photos with my pal Jon Melendez.

Print
clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon

Peanut Butter Love Cookies

★★★★★ 4.5 from 11 reviews
  • Author: Joy the Baker
  • Prep Time: 40 minutes
  • Cook Time: 10 minutes
  • Total Time: 50 minutes
  • Yield: about 24 cookies 1x
Pin Recipe
Print Recipe

Description

A classic Wilson family holiday cookie traditionally made with Hershey’s kisses but made with peanut butter cups for ease in cookie tins for shipment and cookie swaps. 


Ingredients

Scale
  • 1/2 cup (100 grams) granulated sugar, plus more for rolling the dough (optional)
  • 1/2 cup (100 grams) packed brown sugar
  • 1/2 cup (119 grams) creamy peanut butter
  • 1/2 cup (113 grams) unsalted butter, softened
  • 1 large egg
  • 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
  • 1 1/2 cups (192 grams) all-purpose flour
  • 3/4 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
  • About 24 mini Reeses peanut butter cups, unwrapped

Instructions

  1. In large bowl, beat 1/2 cup granulated sugar, the brown sugar, peanut butter, and butter with an electric hand beater until pale and fluffy, 3 to 5 minutes. Beat in the egg and vanilla until well blended, about 1 minute.
  2. Stir in flour, baking soda, baking powder, and salt until a thick cookie dough forms. Transfer the dough to plastic wrap or waxed paper and chill for 30 minutes before baking. 
  3. Place a rack in the upper third of the oven and preheat oven to 375°F. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper and set aside. 
  4. Shape dough into 1 1/2-inch balls and roll in a small bowl of sugar if you’d like. Place  about 2-inches apart on the baking sheet. Press gently with the heel of your hand to flatten just a bit to a thick disc.
  5. Bake for 10 minutes or until edges are light golden brown. Immediately press one reeses candy in center of each cookie. Remove from cookie sheets to cooling rack allowing to cool to room temperature before packaging to allow to chocolate to set. 
  6. Cookies will last, wrapped individually and left at room temperature, for up to 5 days. 

Notes

This dough can be made ahead and frozen for up to two weeks.  I like to portion the prepared dough into balls for baking (not yet rolled in sugar), and freeze until solid on a baking sheet. Once frozen, store in a zip lock bag.  I like to thaw the dough balls in the refrigerator overnight before baking though you can bake them from frozen for an additional 3 or so  minutes (just keep a keen eye). 

Did you make this recipe?

Share a photo and tag us — we can't wait to see what you've made!

Previous PostNext Post

Filed Under: Chocolate, Cookies, Holiday, Recipes, Winter Baking

Previous Post: « Chocolate Peppermint Black and Marble Cookies
Next Post: Let It Be Sunday, 300! »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. tikocookie

    December 21, 2020 at 12:43 pm

    The cookies cracked and spread to much so when I put the mini reese’s, they stood out instead of being envoloped by the cookie. Any idea on how to avoid this in the future?

    ★★★

    Reply
  2. Debby

    December 20, 2020 at 1:02 pm

    Awesome recipe!!! Delicious
    Refrigerator 30 min before is the answer
    Thank you for sharing

    ★★★★★

    Reply
  3. Charlotte

    December 17, 2020 at 8:34 pm

    I made these cookies last weekend and they are delicious! I got the thumbs up from all of my family and was told to add this one to our list of favorites. The peanut butter cookie dough is very light in texture, and even the kid who does not like peanut butter cookies tried one and loved it. Here’s a warning though. You can’t eat just one, you end up eating them in threes!

    Reply
  4. Mike

    December 17, 2020 at 6:18 pm

    Your recipe rocks! I am frustrated, however, by the ads that cover up or interfere with the recipe. I get it… that’s how ya get paid, but placement is everything.

    ★★★★★

    Reply
  5. Emily

    December 12, 2020 at 2:13 pm

    OMG!!! Just made these cookies – amazing!!! Used the mini Reese’s with mini Reese’s Pieces in them – incredible!!

    ★★★★

    Reply
    • Emily

      December 12, 2020 at 2:15 pm

      They are truly 5 star – not sure why only 4 showed up in my original comment?!

      ★★★★★

      Reply
  6. Connie

    December 10, 2020 at 9:05 am

    Coming back in to add the rating that I forgot last night. These are wonderful cookies!! I’m going ot have to give some away so I don’t eat all of them myself!!

    ★★★★★

    Reply
  7. Carolyn

    December 8, 2020 at 10:33 am

    Joy! Happy holidays! We make these every year. So special. Question— where’s your favorite place to get cookie tins? Hope all is well down in New Orleans.

    Reply
  8. Holly

    December 5, 2020 at 1:48 pm

    Off to the store. Mini Reese’s peanut butter cups her I come.

    Reply
    • Holly

      December 6, 2020 at 6:18 pm

      At the bottom of your recipe you wrote “ did you make this recipe? Share a photo and tag us”. How do I do this? In the comment section on this site or on Pinterest or Instagram?

      Reply
  9. Stella

    December 5, 2020 at 9:22 am

    Is it true in the early morning hours calories don’t count? I hope so, these are delicious.

    Reply
  10. dana

    December 5, 2020 at 8:07 am

    This is exactly what I do with a family recipe of ours too! And yes, they are the best.

    Reply
  11. Gigi

    December 5, 2020 at 7:17 am

    Can I use natural organic peanut butter for these or is it just not the same?

    ★★★★★

    Reply
  12. Debra Bures

    December 5, 2020 at 5:09 am

    If you’re making these in the baby hours of the morning, don’t forget to taste the butter, peanut butter, and sugars mixture. You won’t be disappointed. I have read this somewhere.

    Reply
    • bonnie

      December 17, 2020 at 10:14 am

      Baby hours or not, always taste. To pre-check flavors before baking. And for delight! Right, JTB? BTW, This combo is genius, as are you. Beats out the kisses version by miles. Thanks, JTB!

      Reply
  13. Dolly

    December 5, 2020 at 4:22 am

    Can I use chocolate kisses with these cookies?

    Reply
    • joythebaker

      December 6, 2020 at 9:17 am

      Yes of course!

      Reply
  14. Deanne DeCrescenzo

    December 5, 2020 at 4:05 am

    I want to know more about your cookie tin plans! Will you include a note with what’s inside? How many different types of cookies will you include? Like everyone else, I’m pivoting this holiday season and cookie tin deliveries are on my list!!

    Reply
  15. Tara Gutman

    December 4, 2020 at 9:33 pm

    Oh I know what I’m making this weekend!!

    May I ask where your pb cups are from?

    After your Dad’s sweet potato pie and your praline pumpkin pie graced our Thanksgiving table, I’d say were on a roll!

    Looking forward to these.

    Thanks Joy!!

    Reply
    • Meera

      December 6, 2020 at 8:08 am

      They look like the dark chocolate PB Cups from Trader Joe’s, which are AMAZING :)

      Reply
      • Connie

        December 6, 2020 at 10:22 am

        Meera, what a marvelous idea!! And I have some of those already…. My husband is saying those might be too big for a cookie, but I beg to differ!!
        Joy, you are making the choice of which cookies to make very challenging! I THOUGHT the next cookie I was going to make was your chocolate peppermint black and white cookies, but these pb cookies might come first!

        Reply
      • Kristin

        December 7, 2020 at 6:27 pm

        Ha, I bought a containr of the TJ’s dark ones TODAY after seeing thsi recipe and was going to leave a comment to ask how they compare to the Reese’s mentioned, size-wise. Any idea?

        Reply
        • Connie

          December 9, 2020 at 12:56 pm

          Kristin, placing the dark TJs pb cup next to the mini Reeses pb cup – the TJs cup is a little bit taller and has a little more of a diameter. I’m going to make these this afternoon, and I’ll use both to compare.

          Reply
        • Connie

          December 9, 2020 at 7:17 pm

          Kristin, I made these today. I put Hershey kisses on 2, TJs dark choc pb cups on 2, and Reeses pb cups on the rest. The Reeses pb cup cookies look better than the TJs dark choc pb cup cookies, as the Reeses pb cupa melt better than the TJs dark choc pb cups. They both taste great, but the TJs dark choc pb cup cookies are a little less sweet. You can’t go wrong!!

          Reply
          • Kristin

            December 10, 2020 at 1:37 pm

            Connie, you are an angel! And I love that you tried all three – fantastic! And I’m sure it was just “in the name of research”, right? ;-)

        • Connie

          December 10, 2020 at 9:01 pm

          Kristin, of course it was all in the name of research! ;) I’m glad to help!

          Reply
Newer Comments »
Comments Page 1 of 2
1 2 Next »

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe rating ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ ★☆

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

RELATED POSTS IN Chocolate

scoops of ice cream in loaf pan with cones around.
No-Churn Black and White Brownie Ice Cream

This post is sponsored by ALDI! Thank you for supporting the brands that make Joy the Baker possible!  It is ICE CREAM SEASON! (A statement worth shouting from the rooftops) and I have the best-kept secret to beat the heat.   I’ve never really been great with secrets anyway which is why we’re all making the…

Read More

Two huge small-batch chocolate chip cookies.
A Recipe For Just Two Giant Chocolate Chip Cookies

I accidentally went down a rabbit hole a few weeks back.  One afternoon, in a sweet tooth induced mania, I made a small batch of truly giant chocolate chip cookies. The cookie dough came together in a small saucepan, the chocolate almost too melty, and the cookies about the size of my literal face. They…

Read More

sliced chocolate and peanut butter brownies
How To Make Box Brownies Better

I hope we’ve built enough trust between us for you to believe what I’m about to tell you. It’s a secret that professional bakers have been keeping from you for too long.  The truth is BOX BROWNIES ARE BETTER THAN BROWNIES MADE FROM SCRATCH.  I know… criminal, really but facts are facts.  I think it’s…

Read More

Primary Sidebar

Fresh baked emails, delivered to your inbox

Jump to Recipe

Receive recipes from Joy the Baker and updates on events at The Bakehouse.

HI! I’M JOY!

Jump to Recipe

Welcome! This has been my little corner of the internet since 2008!

I’m a baker, photographer, cookbook author and teacher.  I live laugh love in New Orleans. 

MORE ABOUT JOY AND THE TEAM

BOOKS + Magazines

Jump to Recipe

JOY THE BAKER 2022 SUMMER MAGAZINE

JOY THE BAKER 2021 HOLIDAY MAGAZINE

JOY THE BAKER 2020 HOLIDAY MAGAZINE

HOMEMADE DECADENCE

OVER EASY: SWEET AND SAVORY RECIPES FOR LEISURELY DAYS COOKBOOK

JOY THE BAKER COOKBOOK

Jump to Recipe

Joy the baker with dyed bandana around neck

HOW TO MAKE DYED BANDANAS

as seen in JtB Magazine!

Jump to Recipe
joy the baker on facebook joy the baker on twitter pinterest-social instagram-socialbloglovin-social

JOY @ WILLIAMS SONOMA

Jump to Recipe

SHOP THE CAKE LINE OF CAKE MIXES!

DRAKE ON CAKE

Jump to Recipe

Passionate from miles away since 2015.

Check it out on Instagram

Drake on cake instagram.

 

FAVORITE FRUIT RECIPES

strawberry sheet cake on a plate with strawberries on top.

My Favorite Super Easy Strawberry Sheet Cake

Berry crostata topped with whipped cream with coffee.

A Single Serve Berry Crostata Recipe

fresh baked blueberry cobbler on a plate with vanilla ice cream on top.

The Secrets To My Favorite Blueberry Cobbler

POPULAR CAKES

strawberry sheet cake on a plate with strawberries on top.

My Favorite Super Easy Strawberry Sheet Cake

Slice of coconut cake on small white plate with coffee.

My favorite Coconut Cake is actually made with cake mix

A slice of lemon blueberry gooey butter cake held on a cake slicer.

Lemon Blueberry Gooey Butter Cake

Footer

Instagram

joythebaker

📚Baker and author of books and magazines
🎂Creator @drakeoncake
💁🏻‍♀️Classes with me @thebakehousenola
🍰 Products with @williamssonoma

joythebaker
My EASIEST Strawberry Sheet Cake is also my absolu My EASIEST Strawberry Sheet Cake is also my absolute favorite. Get into a box of white cake mix and fresh 🍓🍓 purée! Topped with a thick layer of strawberry cream cheese frosting - this cake is a little pink dream! ⁣
⁣
The Easiest Strawberry Sheet Cake recipe linked in the bio for you! 💋
Our resident reader, @tobyfels shares my favorite Our resident reader, @tobyfels shares my favorite list of the summer on Joy the Baker this year: The Best Books for Summer 2022!  As a person who reads Beach Reads all year long, this is IT! With titles by @ashleymcoleman_ @anarasong @annleary @bonnie_garmus_author @heyashposton @annabelmonaghan @greerhendricks @sarahpekkanen @shelbyvanpeltwrites @marilynsimonrothstein @@misterosman and @kirstin.chen. The guide to your bookworm summer linked in the bio!
Over here testing the limits of “you are what yo Over here testing the limits of “you are what you eat” and will soon be taking my final form as a summer tomato. ⁣🫠🍅
⁣
This Mediterranean Feta and Fresh Tomato Tart is an absolute show stopper with a buttery crisp, press-in crust, whipped feta, and layers of fresh tomato, cucumber, onions, and olives. I’ll leave the recipe linked in the bio - it’s really very special. Join me. We are 🍅🍅.
Here are my two best kept secrets for getting thro Here are my two best kept secrets for getting through this summer.  I’ve never been much for secrets so I’m letting you right in! ⁣
1.	I’m committed to folding crumbled chewy brownies into the easiest homemade no-churn ice cream.⁣
2.	I’m shopping for all of my baking and summer entertaining essentials, wine and cheese at the new @aldiusa stores opening across the Gulf Coast! Wait… you’re as obsessed with ALDI as I am, right? The shopping is always easy and affordable and I always come home with a fun treat among my essentials. Hit up my stories to see my grocery haul (and the chips I ate in the car on the way home) and head to your nearest ALDI for your summer essentials!  #ad⁣
⁣
I’ll leave the recipe and your #ALDILove grocery list linked in the bio!
Let’s just make one! ⁣ ⁣ One Single Berry Cr Let’s just make one! ⁣
⁣
One Single Berry Crostata just you for. Double the recipe (🔗 in the bio) only if you want to share. ⁣
⁣
#joythebaker #berry #crostata #smallbatch #dessert #foodblogfeed
The freezer is packed with ice cream treats from h The freezer is packed with ice cream treats from here on out, and that’s a promise. ⁣
⁣
Find this Milk and Cereal Ice Cream Bar and loads of other semi-homemade ice cream treats linked in the bio! 💓🍦🫠
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2022 · Joy the Baker
All rights reserved. Violators will be whupped and sent to bed with no dessert · Privacy Policy

Scroll Up