Fruit Cake Rugelach Cookies

We’re in the thick of it.  We’re in deep. 

There’s no use fighting the heaps of cookies, the balls of popcorn, the piles of chocolate bark, not to mention the pound of toffee I just devoured… it’s the holiday season and really the best way to show our deepest sentiments is with golden baked sugar in some form, right? 

These Fruit Cake Rugelach are a play one a holiday pink (or is it white?) elephant, that dreaded dense and oddly moist loaf of fruit cake.  

To be fair, Fruit Cake is like Brussels Sprouts…. you think you hate them until you have one done riiiight.  I know how to master a sprout.  Afterall, there’s little that bacon and hard roasting won’t make delicious.  With Fruit Cake though… I thought it best to cut my loses and cookie them, housing simplified fruit cake flavors in tender, rolled cookie dough.  

If you’re making cookies, surely you have a friend who must be making cookies in their kitchen, too!  Invite them (and their cookies) over for a good old-fashioned cookie swap!  The more the merrier as long as there are plenty of cookies, paper cups and boxes to wrap them in.  

In other cookie considerations, please see: Cardamom Spiced Stained Glass Cookies. 

Also… cookie swaps don’t have to be a pre-Christmas-only endeavour.  Those precious days between Christmas and New Year’s day are prime days to bake and exchange treats.  Winter cookies are totally a thing.  

In this Fruit Cake cookie adventure, we’re essentially making sweet dough wedges and rolling them into cookie shapes.  

Here’s what you’ll need to bring these tender cookies filled with fruit together:

•  Softened cream cheese and Crisco® All-Vegetable Shortening (both work to make the dough tender)

•  Granulated sugar and all-purpose flour

•  Dried cherries, golden raisins, pitted dates

•  Brown sugar and ground cinnamon and nutmeg for spice flavor

•  Salt and pure vanilla extract for balance

We’ll start by adding Crisco® All-Vegetable Shortening to the mixing bowl along with cream cheese and granulated sugar.  Mix on low-speed until the three ingredients are well combined.  This may mean stopping the mixer occasionally to scrape down the bowl.  

We’ll add pure vanilla extract, flour, and salt to finish off this soft and tender dough.  It’s really so simple! 

The dough finds its way to a floured counter where we’ll flour it into a soft disk.  

The dough will be a bit sticky, that’s ok!  Just flour it well.  

Divide the disk into equal quarters.  

And wrap each quarter individually.  

The dough will need some time in the refrigerator to chill before rolling out.  

While the dough chills we’ll assemble the filling.  

It starts with brown sugar, granulated sugar, and spices.  We’ll sprinkle this mixture inside the cookies making things understandably delicious.  

Next up, fruit and nuts! 

Walnuts are chopped.  We’ll want all of our fruit and nut filling fairly fine since there’s a lot going into these little cookie rolls.  

Golden raisins finely chopped too.  Sure it’s a sticky endeavor, but entirely worth it.  

You could also use dried apricots if you’re adverse to raisins.  

Plump and dried pitted dates- that earthy sweetness, chopped fine. 

I also added chopped dried cherries.  

The chopped nuts are mixed with the chopped fruit.  

So here’s what we have on hand:

•  sugar and spice mixture

•  chopped fruit and nut mixture

Now it’s time to welcome everything together! 

We’ll start with one of the chilled wedge at a time, leaving the other three dough-brothers in the refrigerator to stay chilled.  

The dough is rolled on a well-floured surface. 

To create a precise circle, I placed a 9-inch round cake pan across the dough and trimmed the edges away.  

The dough will be about 1/4 inch thick.  Thick enough to hold a good schmear of jam, sugar and spice, and fruit and nuts. 

The thicker the base, the easier it is to roll.  

Jam is spread across the dough.  

Cinnamon + sugar is sprinkled generously.

Fruit and nuts, too!

We’ll slice the dough into 12 wedges.  

It’ll look like a fruity sweet pizza and that’s exactly right.  

Now let’s start to rugelach these little gems.  

We’ll start at the wide end of the cookie wedge and lightly but tightly roll the cookie towards the center, gathering all of the jam and fruity goodness inside.  

Place each cookie on a parchment lined cookie sheet, about just and inch or so apart.  

We’ll crack an egg and make a wash for brushing.  

Lightly brush each cookie with beaten egg,

and sprinkle generously with more cinnamon sugar. 

Bake until golden, and bubbling and caramelized around the edges.  

Print

This post is in partnership with Crisco with photographs by Jon Melendez.