Deb’s Caramel Pudding

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

I love when my kitchen is full of hot sugar and warm milk that turns into caramel pudding.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

I love when my kitchen is full of new friends (see Jill, above) who aren’t shy about going in for a giant dollop of whipped cream on their caramel pudding.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

My new friend Jill, from The Dish’s Dish is absolutely obsessed with caramel pudding.  Browned and nutty cooked sugar meets whole milk and sea salt and whipped cream?  Yes.  Definitely obsession worthy.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

I invited Jill over.  I organized the simple ingredients in pretty bowls mostly so I could trick my new friend into thinking I’m super profesh… and…

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

we started cooking sugar.  If you’ve got a new friend in the kitchen, might I suggest that you cook some sugar together?  It’ll really set a happy tone for the rest of your friendship.  Seriously.   Bond over scalding hot sugar.  It’s the best.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

While the sugar cooked and browned, Jill and I patiently waited, and chatted about our mutual obsession with Mt Everest books and shows, laughed at how strange we are,  and took pictures of the stove.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

Once we whisked the cold milk into the hot sugar things got a little chunky… and tense.  Our budding friendship was put to the test.  Would the clumped up caramel dissolve?  Would the milk not curdle?  Oooh goodness.  Jill whisked.  I nervously took pictures of the electrical socket.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

It worked.  Everything worked.  Friendship in tact.  Pudding ready to be strained.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

Individually wrapped caramel pudding ready to chill.  We licked the spatula.  We licked the bowl . It was totally the right thing to do.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

Ooh!  I forgot to mention Jill’s awesome boyfriend Taylor.  He’s a dearheart.  He filmed our caramel pudding making shenanigans.  Thaaaat’s right!  A little video called Bake Out with Jill and Joy…. coming soon.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

But first… let’s just concentrate on the pudding…

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

and the whipped cream and sea salt that are about to top that pudding.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

and my Mom who couldn’t resist a bowl.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

and my new friend Jill who, come to find out, eats whipped cream and frozen M&Ms like… every night.   Let’s just concentrate on those things while our little video is in the editing shop.

Deb's Caramel Pudding with Jill

Just look at these two.  Too beautiful to be true… but they are… true.  It’s crazy.

Jill.  Taylor.  We’ve made caramel pudding.  We have the video to prove it.  We’re friends for life… or at last our bellies are.  I’m totally coming over for whipped cream and frozen M&Ms.  Trust that.

Stay tuned for Bake Out with Jill and Joy.  Coming soon to… you.

Deb’s Caramel Pudding

from Smitten Kitchen

serves 8 small servings or 4 caramel pudding lover servings

Print this Recipe!

Sweet.  Smooth.  Will force you to forget about boring old chocolate or vanilla pudding for the rest of your days.  Topped with coarse sea salt and whipped cream… you might think you’re Sherry Yard and your kitchen is Spago.  You’re not Sherry Yard and your kitchen is not Spago… but for a moment… ooh yes… it will be.

4 cups whole milk

6 tablespoons cornstarch

2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract

1/4 teaspoon salt

1 cup sugar

coarse sea salt and whipped cream for topping

In a small bowl, whisk 1/2 cup of the milk with the cornstarch, vanilla and salt until smooth. Set aside. In a large saucepan, combine the sugar with 6 tablespoons of water and bring to a boil. Cook over moderately high heat, undisturbed, until a deep amber caramel forms, about 8 minutes.  Be sure not to stir the cooking sugar.  If anything, feel free to swirl the pan around a bit.   Be patient but watch the stove like a hawk as caramel changes color quickly.  This is no time for multitasking.  Just stand there and enjoy watching your caramel cook.

Remove from the heat. Very gradually whisk in the remaining 3 1/2 cups of milk.  As you begin whisking it in, the caramel will get very dark and begin to seize with the cold milk.  Not to worry… everything will work out.

Return the pot to the stove and whisk over moderate heat until the caramel has dissolved again. Once again, watch this closely as the milk will foam up quickly as it comes to a simmer. Simmer over moderately low heat until the mixture thickens  just slightly and deepens in color, about 10 minutes.

Gradually whisk the cornstarch mixture into the caramel. Cook again over moderate heat, stirring, until the pudding thickens, about one minute.  The pudding may look and feel pretty loose, but will thicken nicely when chilled in the fridge.

Strain the pudding fine strainer set over a large measuring cup; if you are, you can skip this and nothing terrible will happen. Scrape the pudding into eight 1/2-cup ramekins and refrigerate until chilled and set, about 2 hours.

To avoid a pudding skin press a piece of plastic wrap onto the surface of each pudding dish as it chills.  Top with a generous sprinkle of coarse sea salt and a big ol’ dollop of whipped cream.

102 thoughts on “Deb’s Caramel Pudding

  1. that pudding looks sinfully delicious… so you already got jill cooking with you and her boyfriend filming… for the next video… what about you and simon baking together and someone else can record… Isn’t he the best cupcake decorator ever? and you are both adorable… can’t go wrong! :)

  2. Mmm… that caramel pudding looks fabulous! I wish there were more pictures of your gorgeous self :)

    I can’t wait to see the video! Got to be perfect preparation for that cooking show you’ll be hosting soon…

    I can’t get over how much you make me smile. ;)


    1. Pudding skin, I -love- chocolate pudding skin and now I have to make this so I can have caramel pudding skin!

  3. Perfect practice for that baking show you’re going to host. You know, the show where you win the hearts of millions with your charming personality and your beautiful baking conquests. I can’t wait. :)

Leave a Reply