Chocolate Cherry Yule Log Cake

Grab your pen and get ready to cross something off your Baking Bucket List (you have one of those, right?).  Today we’re making the most festive of holiday cakes and it’s shaped like a log.  Yes, we’re asking our chocolate cake to roll and contort and look like a log of wood for our holiday pleasure. 

If you’re curious about the history of a yule log cake I’ll give you the most Cliff Notes of versions. Yule log cakes start with actual logs, big pieces of wood that were ceremoniously burned in ancient Europe times as a Celtic and Gaelic symbol of the end of long dreary winter days. Time went on, as it does, and giant yule logs became smaller yule logs that were burned in smaller hearths on Christmas Eve.  You know what smaller hearths are good for? You guessed it: baking cakes. 

Enter marzipan. Enter meringues. Enter sponge cake. Find yourself in France and you’ve got yourself a fluffy, cream filled cake shaped like a piece of wood. 

And now here we are, thanks to the many generations of people who burned logs, lived through very cold winters, and wanted cake. Now we’re to muster our very own kitchen courage to roll a warm cake in a towel, fill it with cream to usher in the Yuletide.  

Let’s talk about the nuts and bolts – the cake and filling.  I made a chocolate sponge cake and filled it with cherry-studded whipped cream. It’s a play on my favorite Ben and Jerry’s ice cream flavor, Cherry Garcia. It’s topped with whipped cream, splattered in melted chocolate and surrounded by cherries and greens.  

Ambitious and delicious. I sincerely hope this is your weekend baking project! 

Happy Holidays, friends! 

Here’s what you’ll for your Yule Log baking adventure: 

•  6 eggs, separating the yolks and the whites

•  cream of tartar and salt we’ll beat into the egg whites to set.  

•  granulated sugar to whisk into the egg yolk, creating thick ribbons of yolk. 

•  cocoa powder, flour, and baking powder are our dry ingredients. 

•  melted butter and strong coffee to add moisture, fat, and flavor to our cake batter. 

•  unflavored powdered gelatin is used to create a more stable whipped cream for filling and frosting.

•  heavy cream, powdered sugar, and vanilla. 

•  frozen cherries, if you’d like, for the filling. 

• to decorate, maraschino cherries, rosemary sprigs, melted chocolate, shredded coconut and anything else you might find festive. 

What follows is are step-by-step photos of how this cake comes together for your baking reference. Feel free to scroll aaaallll the way down to the recipe if that’s all you need today.  

We’ll start by working with the eggs, specifically the egg whites.

Beat the eggs whites with cream of tartar and salt until frothy.  Add the granulated sugar and continue to beat the eggs until they increase in volume and hold stiff peaks. This usually takes 5 to 7 minutes. Don’t be discouraged. 

See all the fluff and volume? This is what’s going to make our chocolate cake light, spongey, and most importantly – tender enough to roll.  

Next up, we’ll attend to the egg yolks.  

Cream the egg yolks with the remaining sugar and a splash of vanilla extract.  We want to begin to aerate the egg yolks as well.  

After 3 to 5 minutes the yolks are pale in color and thick enough to temporarily hold the lines of the beaters.  That’s volume we’ll take all the way to the oven. Eggs are magic.  

Beat in the melted butter and coffee.  

Next, we’ll stir the dry ingredients (our flour, cocoa, and baking powder) into the egg yolk mixture.  We’ll have a thick, brownie-like batter on our hands.  

We’ll aerate our rich chocolate batter with the hard working egg whites.  Gently fold the egg whites into the chocolate batter in thirds.  Combine thoroughly, so no white streaks remain. Be conscious of over stirring and deflating the batter. It’s a delicate balance.  I lean towards a few egg white streaks in the batter as opposed to over mixing. 

Grease a 1/2 sheet pan that measures 13×18-inches with nonstick baking spray. Line with parchment and spray the paper too. 

Size matters. We want the cake to bake evenly and thin enough to roll so the half sheet pan is key here. 

The cake will bake for a short 10 to 12 minutes.  The top may still a bit tacky, but the cake should be cooked through when you take it out of the oven.  Remove from the oven and allow to cool for 5 minutes before inverting onto a cocoa and sugar dusted kitchen towel.  Peel back the parchment and thoroughly dust the top of the cake with cocoa sugar, too.  

With our warm cake directly on the kitchen towel, start from the short end and begin to gently roll the cake and towel into a spiral.  

We’re teaching the cake what shape we want it to be. A bit of warm training.  

Let the cake cool to room temperature. 

While the cake cools, we’ll make our whipped cream and filling. 

For this cake, I like to make a stabilized whipped cream – cream that has gelatin beaten into it. It’s a more sturdy whipped cream, and holds its own rolled inside a cake. We don’t want the mush factor and gelatin is our fail safe. 

If you’re opposed or don’t have it on hand and plan to eat your cake rather quickly, you can skip the gelatin game. 

Beat cream, sugar, vanilla and salt. Beat in the gelatin to still and swoopy peeks.  Divide the cream in half or so, and stir chopped cherries into one bowl of cream. If there’s a bowl that has more cream, use that as your cherry filling.  

I used frozen cherries, thawed / drained/ and chopped. 

Take a deep breath and unroll the cake. Spread generously with the cherry filling until it almost reaches each edge of the cake. The filling should be about 1/2-inch thick.  

Using the towel to help you, re-roll the cake. Be gentle. It’s ok if your cake cracks a bit – we’re going to cover it all with more cream. 

You’ve done it! That was all the hardest parts! 

Pat on the back for you! 

Slice a 4 to 6 wedge of one end of the cake and place it to the side like a split log.  

See what you did there? It’s all coming together. 

Top the cake with the remaining whipped cream. 

Use the tines of a fork to trace bark-like marks in the cream.  

Chill the cake while you prepare any other decorations.  

You’re welcome to finish your cake any way that feels sweet to you.  

I tossed a shredded coconut with a dash of green food coloring.  I splattered my cake with chocolate melted with coconut oil. I added maraschino cherries and a few sprigs of rosemary.  More is more. Make yourself happy.  

You’ve got this! Happy holiday caking to you! 

Photos with Jon Melendez. 

Print