The Most Delicious Homemade Doughnuts

Friends, hello!  I’m here to invite you to your next kitchen superpower:  HOW TO MAKE HOMEMADE DOUGHNUTS.  Once you know how to make this homemade doughnut recipe and fry it up, well… there’s no going back. You’ve gone and done it. You’re everyone’s favorite person come weekend brunch.  In my early baking days I was obsessed with learning how to make doughnuts, likely inspired by my family’s Saturday night trips to the 24 hour doughnut shop.

Here’s the thing – making homemade doughnuts isn’t as hard as you might think.  It’s about activating yeast, throwing all of the ingredients in a mixing bowl and having the guts to heat oil to over 300 degrees.  It’s that last part that usually gets people caught up but I think you’re here because you have the guts.  I mean… just look at the rewards!

I’ll walk you from dough to doughnut. Let’s bake!

Here’s what you’ll need for this homemade doughnut recipe:

•  all-purpose flour

•  active dry yeast and warm water to activate it

•  unsalted butter, at room temperature

•  egg yolks for richness

•  whole warm milk

•  kosher salt and granulated sugar

•  ground cinnamon

•  chocolate,  powdered sugar ,and cinnamon sugar for topping the doughnuts

You’ll also want to have round cookie cutter and fry thermometer to set yourself up for success.

We’ll start this homemade doughnut recipe by activating the yeast.  In a small bowl sprinkle yeast over warm water.  Add a tiny pinch of granulated sugar and let the mixture sit for 5 minutes. It will foam and froth once it comes to life.

In the bowl of a stand mixer, stir and combine the rest of the ingredients.  Flour, sugar, salt, milk, butter, and egg yolks.  Add the yeast mixture, too!

I like to use a stand mixer with a large bowl and a dough hook attachment for this homemade doughnut recipe since it’s a relatively soft and slightly sticky dough.  You can certainly bring this dough together by hand, just try not to add too much additional flour as you hand knead it.

Knead the dough on a mixer for 3 to 5 minutes until a soft and cohesive dough forms.  Pillowy soft and moist but not sticky.

You may find that you need to add a few tablespoons of extra flour to make the dough less sticky.  Take it as it comes.  I lean towards keeping the dough sticky rather than adding a ton more flour.

For same-day doughnuts – cover the bowl with plastic wrap (I leave the dough in the large mixer mixing bowl) and allow to rise in a warm place until doubled in size, about 1 1/2 hours.

For overnight doughnuts – cover and refrigerate the dough and refrigerate for 8 to 12 hours.

Next we’ll shape the doughnuts.  For same-day doughnuts, roll the dough to 3/4-inch thickness just after its rise.  I used a 3-inch round biscuit cutter and a 1-inch round for the center holes.  Cover with a clean kitchen towel and let the doughnuts rise for 30 minutes until they’re slightly puffed.

For overnight doughnuts, bring the dough out of the refrigerator and allow the dough to come to a cool room temperature. I usually let the dough rest at room temperature for about 45 minutes before flopping it out on a floured surface, rolling to 3/4-inch thickness and cutting with the rounds.  Allow the shaped doughnuts to rise for 30 minutes.

While you let the dough rise, slowly heat the fry oil over medium heat. You’ll only need a couple of inches of oil in your pan – enough that the doughnuts will float as they fry.

I like a neutral oil like canola oil or peanut oil.

Clip a fry thermometer to the edge of the pan and heat the oil to 360 degrees F.  Really keep an eye on the temperature.  The oil is our oven and we want the oil to be at a consistent heat to evenly fry the doughnuts to golden brown.

The oil temperature will drop to about 350 degrees F when the doughnuts are added. That’s natural. Allow them to fry on both sides  and wait for the the oil to come back up to temperature before adding the next batch. Fry doughnuts for a minute on each side and flip with either a slotted spoon or tongs (though I prefer a slotted spoon or spider).

Fresh out of the oil, allow the doughnuts to rest on a baking sheet on paper towels and coat doughnuts in either powdered sugar or cinnamon sugar.  Allow the doughnuts to cool just a bit before coating in chocolate donut glaze. Chocolate glaze is my favorite, thankyouverymuch.

They’re absolutely irresistible fresh from the fryer.  Like every other doughnut on earth, these gems are best the day they’re fried.

I have more than a few other homemade doughnut recipes for you:

Browned Butter Baked Doughnuts

Cranberry Jam Doughnuts with Orange Sugar

Brûléed Doughnut Holes

Welcome to your new superpower.  Carry on.

Print