The Best Thanksgiving Pies (Classics, Plus the Ones That Deserve More Love)

Pressing the spiced sugar cookie crust into a pie dish for Lemon Meringue Pie, with cut-out dough on a floured counter

Friends, hello and welcome to the weekend before the Food Superbowl! I’m here with pie ideas for Thanksgiving, full disclosure, as a way of putting off my trip to the grocery store. I know it must be done, but my goodness I haven’t yet mustered the mental fortitude.

This weekend’s post-grocery tasks include making a big pot of Chicken and Sausage Gumbo (God bless), and a triple batch of all-butter pie crust. Yes, triple, I’ve made a lot of commitments this year and I want to be ready.

Today’s offerings are all the pies I deeply love that may not get their due at the Thanksgiving dessert table. We’re reaching beyond the standard pumpkin, apple, and sweet potato, here’s that good good.

What are the best pies for Thanksgiving?

The best Thanksgiving pies are the classics (pumpkin, sweet potato, pecan and apple) plus one or two surprises, like a chess pie, a cream pie or a salty honey pie.

Here’s my rule: one classic, one wild card, and one you can make the day before. Everybody’s happy, especially the baker.

Thanksgiving pies, at a glance

Every pie on this page, all from my own kitchen:

Pie Style Good to know
Classic Pumpkin Pie with Chocolate Whip Classic, custard Bake a day ahead, chill overnight, then top
Dad’s Perfect Sweet Potato Pie Classic, custard Coriander, nutmeg and evaporated milk
Bourbon Pecan Pie with Dark Chocolate Classic, nut Cool fully before it goes in the fridge
Apple Praline Pecan Pie Classic, fruit About 6 apples under a praline topping
Fluffy Cranberry Cream Pie Cream, sets in the fridge Chocolate cookie crust, keeps up to 4 days
Classic French Silk Pie Cream Sets in the fridge in 2 hours
Dad’s Lemon Chess Pie Custard Serve at room temperature or chilled
Salty Honey Pie Custard Sweet honey balanced with sea salt
Lemon Meringue Pie Meringue Worth the effort, blind bake the crust
Pumpkin Tarte A La Bouillie Tart Sugar cookie crust, no flaky dough
Apple Cranberry Crumble Fruit Fresh cranberries turn it pink
Bourbon Pear Crumble Fruit Oat and brown sugar crumble
Ina Garten’s Apple Pie Bars Bars Keep up to 5 days in the fridge
Creamy Pumpkin Pie Bars Bars 9 bars, keep up to 4 days in the fridge

The pies that deserve a spot at the Thanksgiving table

Pumpkin Tarte A La Bouillie

A Pumpkin Tarte A La Bouillie is an autumn riff on a Cajun pie. The pumpkin filling is more creamy than a traditional pumpkin pie and the crust is essentially a thick sugar cookie. I love that the crust is less fussy than a traditional flaky pie crust and it comes together in a tart pan with cutie scalloped edges.

Lemon Meringue Pie

It’s impossible to choose a favorite pie but this Lemon Meringue Pie is towards the very top of the list. This pie is admittedly a fair amount of effort so make sure you serve yourself an extra large slice. You may also want to revisit how to blind bake pie crusts. It always takes more pie weights than I think to keep the crust from sinking.

Dad’s Lemon Chess Pie

Dad’s Lemon Chess Pie is a slow bake / easy way to add a lemon moment to the Thanksgiving table. It’s creamy and smooth with a lemon finish. This pie is a family favorite.

Salty Honey Pie

This Salty Honey Pie is a classic from our friends at Sister Pie. It’s a baked custard pie with a deep sweetness and balance from sea salt. I remember giving this pie to my old landlords in Venice who raised their eyebrows and thanked me later.

Apple Cranberry Crumble

We love an apple pie moment, classic. Except I like a twist. Hold some fresh cranberries out of the sauce and throw them into an apple pie. I love how the cranberries soften, tint the whole pie pink, and add the perfect tart pop: Apple Cranberry Crumble.

Bourbon Pear Crumble

Got that bourbon out? This Bourbon Pear Crumble is an oldie here on the blog but such a good one! I love the way pears soften and sweeten when baked. The crumble topping is filled with oats and brown sugar and this pie is just a delight. And while you’ve got the bourbon off the bar, consider: Bourbon Pecan Pie with Dark Chocolate

The classic Thanksgiving pies, done my way

Pumpkin, sweet potato and pecan are the big three, and I’m not here to mess with tradition. Just to make it a little better.

My Classic Pumpkin Pie with Chocolate Whip has a buttermilk crust and a filling with cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, allspice, cloves AND cardamom. Bake it a day ahead, let it chill in the fridge overnight, then pile on the chocolate whipped cream.

Dad’s Perfect Sweet Potato Pie is my dad’s recipe, spiced with coriander and nutmeg and made silky with evaporated milk. Need it gluten-free and dairy-free? My Gluten-Free Sweet Potato Pie has you covered.

For pecan, it’s that bourbon pecan pie with dark chocolate up there. And if you can’t choose between apple and pecan, Apple Praline Pecan Pie is both: about 6 apples under a buttery praline pecan topping. No decisions required.

Thanksgiving pie bars for a crowd

Pie bars are pie for people who don’t want to slice pie. Pressed crust, no rolling pin, and they feed a crowd from one pan.

Ina Garten’s Apple Pie Bars are apple pie in a buttery shortbread situation, and they keep, wrapped, in the fridge for up to 5 days. My Creamy Pumpkin Pie Bars have an oat and pecan crumble with a cream cheese pumpkin filling, they make 9 bars, and they keep up to 4 days in the fridge.

Want a little drama? Pumpkin Pie Bars with Toasted Meringue. Bake the bars the day before, chill them overnight, then pile on the meringue and toast it right before dessert.

Which Thanksgiving pies can you make ahead?

Custard and cream pies are the best make-ahead Thanksgiving pies: pumpkin bakes a day ahead, and cream pies set in the fridge while you do everything else.

My Fluffy Cranberry Cream Pie has a chocolate cookie crust and sets in the fridge (at least 4 hours, overnight is best), so all the oven stress can go to the bird. It keeps up to 4 days covered, but it’s best within 2. Classic French Silk Pie needs just 2 hours in the fridge to set.

And the pie dough? Make it now. Wrapped twice, it freezes for up to 1 month, then thaws in the fridge overnight before you roll it out. Future you says thank you.

For the whole spread (cakes, cookies, the works), here’s my list of the best Thanksgiving desserts.

I hope these pie ideas for Thanksgiving serve you well. Let me know if you have any questions in the comments below! Happy Baking, friends!

All Comments

I Made This

Questions

7 Responses

  1. Glad I already grocery shopped for my pies this year otherwise I’d also be adding the pear crumble to my list!! On my pie list this year are your pumpkin pie from Homemade Decadence, the salted maple pie from Sister Pie, and Erin McDowell’s classic apple pie, as well as her chocolate sugar pie with a toasted meringue topping. Am I doing the most? Yes, yes I am.

  2. I’ve never considered myself a pie person , as mom is (pie for her birthday every year!), but your recipe pictures always make me want to make anything and everything you make! Total inspiration. Let’s see if I (and maybe one or two of my kiddos) can make it into the kitchen. Blessings!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Posts